Devon Sawa REACTS to Christina Ricci's Casper Critique
Chocolate oregon vanilla? Dogs oregon cats? Casper oregon Thackery?
OK, truthful that past 1 mightiness not beryllium as cosmopolitan a question when it comesto defining a person, but for young radical who came of property successful the '90s, it's arguably 1 of the astir important. Casper (Devon Sawa) and Thackery Binx (Sean Murray), the respective ghosts from 1995's Casper and 1993's Hocus Pocus, became two of the astir unexpected heartthrobs of the decennary and their allure continues to haunt us all these years later.
Over the years, there's been countless headlines astir Thackery being a "colonial crush," millennials dissecting that a ghost cat literally led to their intersexual awakening, portion Casper gave them unrealistic expectations for each corporeal lad they would day passim their formative years.
Seeing arsenic however Halloween was the time some Casper and Thackery concisely appeared successful their swoonworthy quality forms, we decided to pit them against 1 different to yet extremity the debate. Welcome to Confusing and Weird Halloween Teen Crushes Thunderdome, let's officially conscionable our competitors:
The Basics:
Universal Pictures
Casper McFadden
Age: 12 (died of pneumonia)
Height: Around 2 feet
Weight: 0 lbs
Hometown: Friendship, Maine
Box Office: $287.9 cardinal worldwide
Thackery Binx
Age: Likely 16 (then lived 300 years arsenic an immortal cat)
Height: Approximately 18 inches
Weight: Approximately 10 lbs
Hometown: Salem, Mass.
Box Office: $39.5 million
Universal Pictures, Disney
Now, let's comparison their stats erstwhile it comes to their respective performances:
The Voice: Ironically enough, some quality actors who portrayed the respective ghostly heartthrobs did not dependable their respective characters, adjacent erstwhile they concisely appeared successful quality form.
American dependable histrion Malachi Pearson provided the vocal chords for Casper, thing Sawa erstwhile poked amusive astatine connected Twitter erstwhile idiosyncratic posted a photograph of the Casper DVD and tagged him successful it.
"I'm not the dependable adjacent successful the the 30 seconds I'm successful it," helium wrote. "Can't instrumentality recognition for anything. Please untag me."
Thackery, meanwhile, was voiced by Boy Meets world histrion Jason Marsden, who primitively auditioned for tie-dye enthusiast Max Dennison (Omri Katz). Now here's wherever it gets a small weird: After being called backmost to work for Thackery, Marsden landed the role...sort of. While Murray had been formed arsenic Binx, the filmmakers wanted Marsden to dependable the character, meaning Marsden (who was besides friends with Murray!) had to dub the lines for some the feline and quality forms of the character.
However, Marsden revealed Murray's dependable was initially used, saying successful a 2019 interrogation with The Daily Beast, "They were utilizing him archetypal and animating his performance. It's perfectly nary detriment to Sean, who's a person and fantastic actor. It's 1 of those things that hap successful movies each the time. Movies are shot, written, spell into production, and past instrumentality connected a dependable of their own. Sean has a precise modern sound."
Murray wasn't excessively bothered by the decision, telling Bustle in 2018, "They primitively wanted a benignant of California vibe with the voice, and past astatine immoderate constituent thought [they] should bash it Olde English. I'm not a dependable actor; I couldn't bash an English accent, I'd ne'er been trained to bash that, and I was young."
Winner: Draw.
The Kiss: So this 1 truly isn't fair, arsenic Thackery's is conscionable a saccharine feature peck helium gives Dani (Thora Birch) aft helium is yet capable to transverse implicit arsenic a human. (Let's not adjacent sermon the years of therapy that miss astir apt went done aft her archetypal emotion was an immortal cat.) It's precise touching, but she's 8 years old, ya know?
Universal Pictures
Casper, however, is simply a antithetic story. From the infinitesimal helium walked down those stairs, it was connected similar Donkey Kong. Casper and Kat's dilatory creation astatine the Halloween creation was virtually a mediate schoolhouse girl's DREAM. And their buss arsenic they levitated helped galore a instrumentality transverse implicit into not-a-girl-not-yet-a-woman territory. It besides helped that Sawa and Ricci, who had worked unneurotic (and kissed) connected 1994's Now & Then had chemistry to rival the greats!
Even much haunting? They astir chose to extremity the movie without showing Casper successful quality form. THOSE FOOLS.
"It was crazy, due to the fact that they didn't cognize whether that was going to beryllium the ending oregon not," Sawa told The A.V. Club successful 2012. "I deliberation [executive producer] Steven Spielberg decided successful the past mates of weeks of shooting to sprout an alternate ending of Casper coming backmost arsenic a existent boy. And past they went with that ending."
Can you ideate each of the intersexual awakenings that would've been stalled—possibly forever—had they not gone with that endings?
Winner: Casper.
Iconic Line: Casper's "Can I support you?" vs. Thackery's "I shall ever beryllium with you"?
Winner: Casper.
Sense of Style: Listen, some boys were consecutive up livin' for that escaped achromatic blouse look, so...
Winner: Draw.
The Legacy: Alright, this is tough, due to the fact that you request to abstracted the characters from the movies' legacies. While some Casper and Hocus Pocus person endured arsenic Halloween classics and 2 of the season's astir beloved (and played) films, Hocus Pocus' fable has lone grown with time, turning into a cult classical that wasn't afloat appreciated erstwhile it was released successful July 1993.
Freeform ever kicks off its iconic 31 Days of Halloween programming with Hocus Pocus, and volition virtually play it for 24 hours consecutive connected Halloween. Plus, its long-awaited sequel yet premiered connected Sept. 30 and rapidly acceptable a steaming grounds for Disney+. So, erstwhile it comes to his movie's legacy, the victor is Thackery.
However, when it comes to quality legacy, Casper has the advantage, arsenic the quality spawned a fewer direct-to-film sequels, video games and a deed animated series. Thackery, meanwhile, has endured much arsenic a confusing entity of our teen affection and immoderate radical inactive deliberation his sanction is Zackary.
Winner: Casper.
Jim Smeal/Shutterstock, MediaPunch/Shutterstock
Now let's look astatine the actors' relationships with their respective characters decades later.
Aside from Casper, Sawa's turns successful Little Giants, Now & Then and Wild America made the Canadian a full-blown teen idol, with his representation serving arsenic wallpaper successful galore bedrooms successful the '90s.
"There was a constituent wherever Jonathan [Taylor Thomas] and I were successful London, and we shared a limo," Sawa told The A.V. Club. "It was, like, [we were] The Beatles! They were chasing our car and smacking the windows, and that's erstwhile I yet realized that, 'Holy s--t, this is getting crazy.'"
Also, Sawa, present 44 and a begetter of two, is down for a sequel! (He besides loves to poke amusive astatine his teen heartthrob past and has an ongoing faux-feud connected societal media with Home Alone prima Macaulay Culkin.)
Alright, I cognize it's been awhile.. but I deliberation I'm yet acceptable to bash a Casper sequel.
— devon sawa (@DevonESawa) January 27, 2017Murray's clip arsenic Thackery didn't pb to him taking implicit the pages of Tiger Beat or J-14, but helium continued to work, making appearances connected TV bid similar ER, Touched By an Angel and starring successful TV movies, earlier landing a relation connected NCIS successful 2003. That's right, Binx got that CBS procedural wealth arsenic NCIS is inactive connected the aerial contiguous and is 1 of TV's astir palmy play bid ever.
Though helium doesn't speech astir his acquisition moving on Hocus Pocus much, Murray, besides 44 and a begetter of two, opened up astir playing 1 pf popular culture's astir beloved cats successful an interrogation with Bustle in 2018.
"I see myself precise fortunate to beryllium a portion of that," helium said. "It was a truly bully clip and I learned a lot. I'll ever retrieve it fondly."
And connected the 25th day of the movie's release, Murray acknowledged the milestone connected Instagram (though helium did not look during Freeform's Hocus Pocus 25th Anniversary Halloween Bash TV special).
Winner: Casper.
ULTIMATE WINNER: It was a adjacent call, but Casper yet takes the crown successful this ghastly (and astir apt somewhat inappropriate) debate, not similar helium could deterioration it though.
(Originally published connected Thursday, Oct. 31 2019, astatine 1:00 p.m. PT)
For the latest breaking quality updates, click present to download the E! News App