2 years ago
43
Kristin Smart Murder Trial: Paul Flores Found Guilty
Kristin Smart went retired with immoderate friends on May 24, 1996, hoping to find a Friday nighttime enactment to footwear disconnected the agelong Memorial Day weekend.
But first, the 19-year-old called her parents, letting them cognize successful the connection she near connected their answering instrumentality that she had "good news" and would telephone again connected Sunday.
"She was precise excited," her mom, Denise Smart, told the Los Angeles Times successful 2006, recalling however Kristin shared that her biology prof was letting her retake an exam that had inexplicably gone missing earlier that quarter. "She said, 'Hi, bully news, bully news.' That was her bully news: She had gotten a telephone from prof immoderate his sanction was. She had been trying for truthful agelong to get that resolved."
Denise figured they'd drawback up connected Sunday, arsenic they ever had during Kristin's freshman twelvemonth astatine Cal Poly San Luis Obispo.
Kristin—the eldest of 3 siblings, who wrote poesy and had worked arsenic a lifeguard successful her hometown of Stockton—did find a party. But she never made it backmost to her dorm.
On Oct. 18, 45-year-old Paul Flores was convicted of Kristin's murder.
He has pleaded not guilty, his lawyer arguing that nary 1 could beryllium 100-percent definite that Kristin, whose body has never been found, was adjacent dead. Paul's father, Ruben Flores, 81, accused of helping hide the teen successful his backyard aft his lad killed her, was recovered not blameworthy of being an accessory to murder.
"Without Kristin, determination is nary joyousness oregon triumph with this verdict, we each cognize it did not person to beryllium this way," the Smart household said successful a statement to E! News. "We volition ne'er beryllium capable to perceive Kristin's engaging laughter oregon revel successful her embrace. Her hopes and dreams volition ne'er beryllium realized; nary signifier of justness tin bring these back."
"After 26 years, with today's divided verdicts," they continued, "we learned that our quest for justness for Kristin volition continue. We admit and we are beyond grateful for the diligence of some juries and our religion successful the justness strategy has been renewed by knowing the antheral who took Kristin's beingness volition nary longer beryllium escaped to maltreatment different household oregon victim."
Uncredited/AP/Shutterstock
What really happened connected the night Kristin Smart disappeared?
According to myriad accounts of that night told to authorities and subsequently reported on, astatine astir 8:30 p.m. connected May 24, Kristin and 3 girlfriends left campus connected ft and soon caught a thrust in another pal's truck. After driving astir for a mates of hours, Kristin suggested they spell to a day party being thrown by immoderate fraternity brothers astatine a adjacent house.
But Kristin was the lone 1 who wanted to go, truthful she got retired of the vehicle astir 2 blocks distant from the enactment connected Crandall Way.
"I tin inactive spot her lasting determination aft we dropped her off, a small huffy I deliberation that I wouldn't spell with her," her person Margarita Campos told the San Luis Obispo Telegram-Tribune (now conscionable Tribune) in 1997. "Someone who wasn't arsenic autarkic arsenic Kristin wouldn't person gone to a enactment alone. She kept saying, 'You spell with me.' But I didn't privation to go. I told her, 'You amended beryllium careful,' and she said she would beryllium fine. Then she said 'Bye.'"
At that constituent successful the evening, according to Kristin's friends, nary of them—including Kristin—had been drinking.
Witnesses aboriginal told authorities that Kristin seemed intoxicated when she near the party, with 1 idiosyncratic claiming they saw her drinking tequila portion constabulary were besides told she was chugging vodka. Still different partygoers said they ne'er saw her with a drink.
One person told police, per the LA Times, that it wouldn't person been unheard of for Kristin to enactment tipsier than she truly was. When going done her emails, investigators besides learned that she sometimes tried connected antithetic names for size, finding messages signed with a assortment of monikers, including Roxie and Trixie.
She picked Roxie for this peculiar nighttime out.
Axel Koester/Sygma via Getty Images
Kristin's parents described her as a warm, kind, fun-loving and adventurous but sometimes anxious girl, 1 who worked arsenic a campy counsellor connected Oahu and traveled to Venezuela connected an speech programme but was frightened to get her driver's license. She called her ma each week and wasn't loving assemblage truthful far, but was trying. Investigators recovered that she ended her email messages with, "Live your beingness to beryllium an EXCLAMATION, alternatively than an EXPLANATION."
Her father, Stan Smart, told the LA Times, "We thought [Cal Poly, astir a four-hour thrust from Stockton] would beryllium a bully spot for her. We thought it was a harmless community, you know. And it is. It conscionable didn't enactment retired that mode for our family."
At 6-foot-1 and fit from years of swimming, Kristin besides chopped a striking figure. She had dyed her naturally blonde hairsbreadth brownish during the schoolhouse twelvemonth and, the mercury hovering astatine 80 degrees connected the nighttime of May 24, friends remembered her casually dressed in black moving shorts with a cropped T-shirt and red sneakers.
During the party, Kristin—who had told immoderate radical that her sanction was Roxie—was seen astatine 1 constituent with Paul Flores, besides a 19-year-old freshman. At astir 2 a.m. erstwhile the enactment was breaking up, she was heading retired with fellow students Tim Davis and Cheryl Anderson, when Paul joined them "out of nowhere," Cheryl testified successful a deposition reported connected by the LA Times.
When they got backmost to campus, Tim went successful a antithetic direction, toward his dorm, Cheryl telling Tim the remainder of them could get backmost location on their own. The trio got to Cheryl's gathering first, Cheryl told investigators, recalling that Paul said he'd beryllium definite to get Kristin backmost to her country safely. They went backmost and distant a little, Cheryl said, explaining that she would person walked Kristin backmost herself if Paul hadn't insisted he'd bash it.
She said that she didn't retrieve Kristin saying thing connected the locomotion home. Paul was keeping an limb astir her, seemingly to assistance her along, and on a fewer occasions erstwhile Kristin stopped walking, Paul told Cheryl she was escaped to spell connected ahead. When they got to her building, Cheryl added, Paul asked her for a buss goodnight, which she recovered weird, and past erstwhile she declined, a hug. Maybe she shook his hand, she recalled.
Then helium and Kristin walked disconnected into the night.
Axel Koester/Sygma via Getty Images
Paul told field constabulary that, arsenic they approached their respective residence halls, helium and Kristin went their abstracted ways.
He had a achromatic eye, helium explained, from playing pickup hoops the Monday aft the party. (A chap subordinate told the cops that Paul showed up with the achromatic oculus and, erstwhile asked wherever helium got it, claimed helium conscionable woke up with it.) In a consequent interrogation with field police, Paul said helium sustained the wounded portion doing repair enactment connected a motortruck astatine his father's location but hadn't wanted to "sound stupid" before.
A constabulary study stated that Paul's roommate, who had been distant for the weekend, said Paul told him of the nighttime successful question that helium walked Kristin to her dorm and went backmost to his room. But besides helium had teased Paul astir the case, the roommate added, and erstwhile helium asked Paul "what helium did" with Kristin, Paul said, "She's location with my parents."
Paul appeared earlier a expansive assemblage successful October 1996, 1 of 8 radical subpoenaed to springiness evidence. He invoked his Fifth Amendment close to not incriminate himself and his grounds lone lasted for astir 5 minutes.
Meanwhile, immoderate friends had gone looking for Kristin aboriginal that play erstwhile she failed to crook up and knocks connected her doorway went unanswered. But authorities reportedly weren't alerted until Kristin's roommate, Crystal Calvin, returned to the dorm connected Monday, May 27, and saw Kristin's purse and different idiosyncratic items successful the country wherever she'd past seen them Friday. She called the University Police Department twice, and later that time they reached retired to Kristin's parents to spot if she was astatine location with them.
"When they archetypal contacted us, similar immoderate parent, I was frustrated to deliberation that she'd done thing embarrassing," dad Stan told the San Francisco Examiner in 1998.
Per the LA Times, successful the University Police's May 28 study archetypal documenting that Kristin was missing, an serviceman wrote, "Smart appeared to beryllium nether the power of intoxicant connected Friday night. Smart was talking with and socializing with respective antithetic males astatine the party. Smart lives her beingness successful her ain way, not conforming to emblematic teenage behavior."
The past condemnation of the study read, "These observations are successful nary mode implying that her behaviour caused her disappearance, but they supply a representation of her behaviour connected the nighttime of her disappearance."
Why was the investigation into Kristin Smart's disappearance truthful frustrating?
Margarita Campos said connected the Nov. 28, 2020, occurrence of CBS News' 48 Hours that, erstwhile they parted ways connected the nighttime successful question, Kristin didn't person money, ID oregon her keys, truthful Margarita gave Kristin her key to fto herself backmost into the residence hallway later.
"I was expecting her to sound connected my doorway and be, like, 'Oh, Margarita, you missed a rager. And here's your key,'" Margarita said. "I knocked connected her door, and I thought she was conscionable sleeping, oregon she went retired and about, you know?" As for the field police, she recalled, "They were, like, 'Are you definite she didn't spell retired of town?' It's, like, she has thing connected her...How could she person gone retired of town?"
"To this day, like, I was like, why—why did I conscionable fto her spell by herself?...I did person guilt astir that," Margarita said. "But you person to understand, she was a truly autarkic escaped spirit."
Authorities besides entertained the anticipation that Kristin had simply tally away, a conception her parent didn't judge for a second, nary substance overmuch she hoped her girl was live and well. Talking to the Los Angeles Times in 2006, Denise recalled feeling arsenic if investigators were treating Kristin "like a mislaid bicycle."
Searchers conducted a excavation at the landfill wherever the Cal Poly trash was dumped several days aft Kristin disappeared, but it was reportedly 4 weeks earlier field constabulary reached retired out to the San Luis Obispo Sheriff's Department for assistance.
Why did constabulary fishy Paul Flores of being progressive successful Kristin Smart's disappearance?
Soon, however, investigators honed successful on Paul, a below-average pupil who, according to what his parents told police, had nary friends successful precocious schoolhouse and hadn't recovered overmuch societal occurrence successful college, either.
In December 1995, different pistillate pupil had called the San Luis Obispo Police on him after helium climbed up a trellis and refused to get disconnected her balcony, but helium near earlier officers arrived. Six weeks aft that, helium was caught speeding his motortruck done an intersection and, aft blowing a .13 (.08 being the ineligible limit) connected a breathalyzer, helium mislaid his license.
"[On] play nights," a instrumentality enforcement root told the LA Times, "he'd beryllium successful his country and portion beer, get drunk and past spell rotation astir the outskirts of campus, looking for parties."
Per that source, Tim Davis, a elder who helped propulsion the enactment earlier walking portion of the mode location with Kristin, Cheryl and Paul, told investigators helium "saw Paul Flores connected apical of Kristin Smart," whose sanction helium thought was Roxie, successful the hallway. "He didn't cognize if Flores had knocked Kristin Smart down connected intent oregon if it was an accident." Paul and Kristin got up, according to Tim, and went their abstracted ways.
Tim besides said, per the source, that helium saw "Roxie" astatine the extremity of the nighttime lying down extracurricular connected the next-door neighbor's lawn. He went implicit to aftermath her up and she told him she was cold.
Authorities thoroughly believed that Paul was their guy, that helium was the lone 1 who could accidental for definite what happened to Kristin. Four antithetic scent dogs led constabulary to Paul's dorm, an indicator that she had been there. But arsenic weeks turned into months and months turned into years, that was technically lone a working theory, arsenic nary hint of the teen's assemblage was ever found.
Axel Koester/Sygma via Getty Images
How galore years went by in the hunt for answers astir Kristin Smart's fate?
Kristin's parents, meanwhile, were besides convinced of Paul's guilt, suing him for wrongful decease successful 1996 successful hopes of getting him to uncover much astir that night. In a 1997 deposition, Paul invoked his Fifth Amendment close not to incriminate himself successful effect to each question different than "What is your name?"
The Smarts besides kept their ain files connected the case—and kept tabs connected Paul, sending members of his household photos of Kristin successful their myriad pleas to get them to talk. All of the packages were returned, aft being opened, to the Smarts.
Denise and Stan kept the hunt for Kristin going aft constabulary enactment tapered off, giving interviews successful bid to support her sanction and look successful the news, contacting the FBI and authorities lawmakers. In 1997, the California legislature passed the Kristin Smart Campus Safety Act, which requires field constabulary to promptly study missing students to section instrumentality enforcement and for the entities to formally enactment retired which agency will instrumentality the pb successful the lawsuit of a convulsive crime.
"It's been similar having an unfastened coiled and having idiosyncratic continually pouring brackish successful it," Denise told the Examiner in 1998. "Having a missing kid is conscionable not thing that gets amended implicit time. It's different dimension, and it conscionable can't heal." (A lawyer who had antecedently represented Paul told the paper that determination were "no facts to bespeak that Paul had thing to bash with the disappearance of Kristin Smart.")
And, Denise insisted, "we're not aft Paul Flores...We're aft our daughter. We lone privation our girl back."
Two twelvemonth aft his girl went missing, Stan Smart was inactive going to Cal Poly astir erstwhile a period to hunt for Kristin, oregon traces of her, himself.
"Stan feels similar sometimes helium conscionable needs to spell there, to beryllium there," Denise explained. "I'm conscionable the opposite. It's excessively chilling, excessively hard for maine to beryllium there."
Denise Pearce, a household person who utilized to person Kristin babysit her kids, told the Examiner that Kristin "would beryllium truthful grateful, but truthful amazed that she would person gotten this overmuch attention."
The case—beautiful, vibrant assemblage pupil goes missing without a trace—naturally captivated the media astatine archetypal and tips poured in as to Kristin's supposed whereabouts, each disappointments successful the end.
Carolyn Cole/Los Angeles Times/Shutterstock
But adjacent erstwhile the archetypal frenzy quieted down, the probe was often revisited implicit the years. Amateur sleuths took up the lawsuit arsenic well, chat rooms and connection boards giving mode to societal media and Reddit threads. The astir notable heavy dive of precocious came courtesy of musician Chris Lambert's 2019-2020 podcast Your Own Backyard, seemingly a motion some to the proximity of the transgression to wherever helium grew up and authorities' suspicion that Paul had buried Kristin adjacent to home.
The result, however, was ever the aforesaid frustrating dormant end, that Kristin's slayer was retired determination and it was nary secret as to whom the constabulary suspected, but there were nary arrests and nary charges.
"Because of inconsistencies successful his activities, oregon claimed activities during that period, we judge helium has further cognition astir what happened, and helium is simply a fishy successful her disappearance," Sgt. Bill Wammock of the San Luis Obispo County Sheriff's Department told the Examiner, referring to Paul Flores, successful 1998. "This has been a frustrating lawsuit for us, for the parents, for the press, due to the fact that we don't person an reply to what happened here."
Kristin was formally declared dormant successful 2002. In 2006, sheriff's spokesperson Sgt. Brian Hascall called Paul an "active suspect" and the probe "open and active."
Talking to the LA Times in 2006, 10 years after Kristin disappeared, Stan said, "Nothing truly has changed. I mean, I inactive person a batch of choler astir the situation. And my woman is simply a spot of an affectional wreck astatine times. And it hasn't been resolved. We haven't truly resolved the issues arsenic to wherever our girl is, and what happened to her."
Uncredited/AP/Shutterstock
What was the large interruption successful the Kristin Smart case?
But investigators ne'er gave up the quest to make their case.
The Smart probe showed caller signs of life in 2020 erstwhile Paul's Los Angeles-area residence and vehicles were searched for "specific items of evidence," arsenic noted successful the hunt warrant. The San Luis Obispo Sheriff's Department besides obtained a wiretap for his calls and substance messages. Four different residences successful California and Washington were searched past year, arsenic well, including Paul's parent Susan's residence in Arroyo Grande, Calif.
And connected April 13, 2021, 7 weeks shy of the 25th day of Kristin's disappearance, Paul, present 45, was arrested and the adjacent day charged with first-degree murder, authorities alleging that connected the greeting of May 25, 1996, helium tried to sexually battle Kristin successful his dorm country and, successful the people of events, killed her and past buried her assemblage successful his father's yard. He has pleaded not guilty.
At arraignment his lawyer, Robert Sanger, said Paul "denies each allegation, peculiar oregon otherwise," against him. Moreover, helium added, the affidavit which prompted a justice to motion disconnected connected his client's apprehension warrant contained "very little" accusation that wasn't already a "matter of nationalist record, blogging, speculation and whatnot for implicit 20 years."
Uncredited/AP/Shutterstock
Deputy Dist. Atty. Christopher Peuvrelle offered that Sanger "must not person work the aforesaid warrant I did."
Paul's father, Ruben Flores, was besides arrested astatine his location successful Arroyo Grande and charged with accessory after the information of murder for allegedly helping Paul fell Kristin's body. He pleaded not blameworthy and was released connected $50,000 bail into his ex-wife's supervision and fitted with an ankle bracelet monitor.
Peuvrelle, who prosecuted some begetter and son, said astatine Ruben's bail hearing that the excavation beneath the defendant's deck "showed damning grounds that a assemblage had been buried successful that determination and past precocious moved."
Daniel Dreifuss/AP/Shutterstock
Ruben's attorney, Harold Mesick, countered that the alleged grounds against his client—disrupted soil—was "so minimal arsenic to daze the conscience."
Paul, who moved to Southern California successful the precocious 1990s and was arrested successful San Pedro, was denied bail and has been successful custody since his arrest. The proceedings was moved to Monterey County, astir 126 miles distant from San Luis Obispo, a justice having granted the defendants' petition for a alteration of venue.
In his opening connection arsenic Paul's execution proceedings got underway July 18, Sanger, his attorney, maintained that determination was nary assemblage and truthful inactive nary execution case. Whatever happened to Smart was "obviously...a tragic concern successful 1 consciousness oregon another," helium said. "It is believed she is deceased, but determination is nary grounds of what happened to her aft Paul Flores near her."
Axel Koester/Sygma via Getty Images
At a property league announcing the arrests successful April 2021, San Luis Obispo County Sheriff Ian Parkinson, who'd held the top occupation since 2011, acknowledged that, successful the days instantly pursuing Kristin's disappearance, "mistakes were made, and that made things overmuch much difficult."
But, helium besides said, successful the anterior 10 years his investigators had executed much than 40 hunt warrants, recovered 193 caller items of evidence, conducted 138 in-person interviews and had dozens of pieces of grounds re-examined. And portion helium inactive couldn't spell into definite details at the time, helium added, they had recovered carnal grounds related to Kristin's decease successful 2 homes and their grounds included trucks that belonged to the Flores household erstwhile she disappeared.
Denise and Stan Smart credited Parkinson for being "true to his word," saying successful a connection astatine the time, "We person kept the faith; ne'er fixed up; and afloat placed our spot and enactment with him and his team. The task helium and his squad accepted was unprecedented successful measurement and scope, yet they met each setback and situation with resoluteness and an unequaled committedness to Kristin and our family."
Kristin Smart
The Smarts' longtime lawyer James Murphy—who filed the wrongful decease suit connected their behalf in 1996 and has had a billboard touting a $75,000 reward for accusation starring to Kristin's whereabouts successful his beforehand gait since 1997—told 48 Hours aft the Flores arrests, "To spot them successful custody was a feeling of large joyousness for me...My occupation was to hunt them. And that's what I've been doing for a long, agelong time, on with a batch of different people. That's been our goal."
Denise and Stan are "interested successful seeing Paul Flores get convicted and Ruben Flores get held accountable," Murphy continued, but "most importantly they privation to find their daughter."
He promised them the billboard would enactment up until that happened.
In their connection pursuing the verdicts, Kristin's household again thanked Lambert, Parkinson, Peuvrelle, District Attorney Dan Dow and others for ne'er giving up.
"Our household is comforted and strengthened by the cognition that Kristin continues to beryllium held successful the hearts and memories of many," they said. "We volition ne'er beryllium capable to personally convey everyone, but delight cognize our gratitude and emotion goes retired to each of you who person been with america connected this long, overwhelming, and affectional journey. We are everlastingly stronger together.
"Most importantly, to our Kristin: Almost 3 decades ago, our lives were irreparably changed connected the nighttime you disappeared. We anticipation this verdict helps present not conscionable answers, but besides a bid and consciousness of closure that person eluded america for 26 years. Know that your tone lives connected successful each and each 1 of us, each day. Not a azygous time goes by wherever you aren't missed, remembered, loved, and celebrated."
(Originally published May 25, 2021, astatine 4 a.m. PT)
For much existent transgression updates connected your need-to-know cases, caput to Oxygen.com.
