Miley Cyrus Sued Over "Flowers" Allegedly Copying Bruno Mars Song
Miley Cyrus isn’t giving immoderate of her hours to this plagiarism allegation.
After Tempo Music Investments, who partially owns the copyright to “When I Was Your Man” by Bruno Mars, sued the Disney alum and her co writers for allegedly plagiarizing the way successful her Grammy-winning opus “Flowers,” Miley’s squad has filed for the case’s dismissal.
In documents submitted Nov. 20 and obtained by E! News, ineligible practice for Miley, co writers Gregory Hein and Michael Pollack, Sony Music, arsenic good arsenic different companies attached to the opus allege that the ailment filed by Tempo, lacks “information capable to signifier a content arsenic to the information oregon falsity of the allegations,” and therefore, contradict each allegations made successful the archetypal filing, pertaining to copyright infringement.
The effect further alleges that Miley and her co defendants are not required to taxable an reply based connected the aforementioned deficiency of accusation successful the archetypal filing. As they enactment that the original allegations successful Tempo’s filing “consist of ineligible conclusions to which nary effect is required.”
Due to the deficiency of evidence, the ineligible squad representing Miley is requesting the suit beryllium “dismissed with prejudice,” adding that Tempo volition screen the ineligible costs and “further alleviation arsenic the Court deems proper.”
Miley’s effect comes two months aft Tempo filed the suit Sept. 16.
“Any instrumentality of Bruno Mars’ ‘When I Was Your Man’ knows that Miley Cyrus’ ‘Flowers’ did not execute each of that occurrence connected its own," the archetypal filing’s documents, obtained by E! News, alleged. “‘Flowers' duplicates galore melodic, harmonic, and lyrical elements of 'When I Was Your Man,' including the melodic transportation plan and series of the verse, the connecting bass-line, definite bars of the chorus, definite theatrical euphony elements, lyric elements, and circumstantial chord progressions.”
Kevin Mazur/Getty Images for The Recording Academy
The documents further reason that it is “undeniable” that Miley’s Best Pop Solo Performance Grammy triumph “would not exist” without Bruno’s 2012 song, which besides received a information successful the aforesaid class astatine the 2013 Grammys (“Royals” by Lorde took the win).
Miley’s “Flowers” sat connected the apical of the Billboard charts for a combined 106 weeks aft its January 2023 release, with 8 being connected the Hot 100. In summation to its illustration success, it besides earned her two Grammy wins, her archetypal ever aft lone 1 anterior nomination.
And portion the occurrence of “Flowers” is simply a archetypal for her, Miley antecedently spoke retired astir her deficiency of designation by the Recording Academy anterior to 2023.
“No shade, but I've been doing this for 20 years, and this is my archetypal clip really being taken earnestly astatine the Grammys?" Miley incredulously asked successful a W magazine interrogation successful June. “I've had a hard clip figuring retired what the measurement is there, due to the fact that if we privation to speech stats and numbers, past wherever the f--k was I? And if you privation to talk, like, interaction connected culture, past wherever the f--k was I?”
She emphasized, “This is not astir arrogance. I americium arrogant of myself."
For much details connected Miley’s evolution, support reading…
For the latest breaking quality updates, click present to download the E! News App