Can you judge it's been 10 years since Microsoft first launched the Surface? That's a decennary of trying to marque hybrid tablet PCs a thing, thing I'm inactive not definite galore radical really want. But, you cognize what, I'll springiness Microsoft recognition for trying to propulsion laptop designs guardant successful an epoch erstwhile everyone was trying to transcript Apple's unibody MacBook Pro and ultra-thin MacBook Air. The Surface was a extremist alternative.

The Surface Pro 9 with 5G makes it wide that Microsoft has learned immoderate lessons since its archetypal tablets: It's impeccably designed, and it's the archetypal Surface to pat into speedy 5G networks. Unfortunately, it's besides a disappointing reminder that Microsoft can't assistance but repetition galore of its earlier mistakes. It's yet different ARM-based Windows PC that we can't perchance recommend.

That's not precisely surprising, fixed our lukewarm absorption to the ARM-powered Surface Pro X line. But what's much galling this twelvemonth is that Microsoft is really calling it the Surface Pro 9 with 5G, arsenic if it's straight comparable to the Surface Pro 9 powered by Intel's 12th-gen chips. That's much than hubris – it's an outright lie, 1 that volition undoubtedly confuse shoppers and IT workers for the adjacent year.

Sure, they some person the aforesaid gorgeous and impressively bladed aluminum case, 13-inch PixelSense display, and precise usable keyboard covers (which are unluckily inactive sold separately). Both models besides person the aforesaid built-in kickstand, which lets you prop up the surface connected a table, oregon if you're feeling risky, connected your limb for on-the-go computing. If you've seen a Surface tablet before, particularly past year's coagulated Pro 8, not overmuch has changed.

Devindra Hardawar/Engadget

A communicative of 2 Surfaces

Here's the rub: Microsoft present has 1 merchandise enactment moving connected 2 precise antithetic spot designs, Intel's x86 hardware and Microsoft's customized SQ3 ARM system-on-a-chip (itself based connected Qualcomm's Snapdragon 8cx Gen 3). The Intel-powered Surface Pro 9 tin tally each of the bequest Windows apps you'd expect. The SQ3 model, connected the different hand, tin lone tally newer apps natively. Everything other is emulated, starring to importantly slower performance. On the positive side, Windows 11 supports x64 emulation now, truthful the Pro 9 with 5G tin tally plentifulness of apps that the Pro X couldn't erstwhile it launched. But that doesn't screen games, and it's a compromise I don't deliberation anyone should beryllium making astatine this point.

What's adjacent much frustrating is that Microsoft is making you wage a $300 premium supra the $999 Surface Pro 9 for the privilege of owning an inherently slower computer. How overmuch is built-in 5G worthy to you, then?

Devindra Hardawar/Engadget

A amended Windows connected Arm experience, but not by much

After utilizing the Pro 9 with 5G for respective days, I'm adjacent much baffled by Microsoft's reckless effort astatine shoving its x86 and ARM merchandise lines together. While a fewer of the company's engineers assured maine successful a caller interrogation that the show would beryllium comparable betwixt the SQ3 and Intel models, I knew that was inaccurate the infinitesimal I launched Chrome. As an emulated x86 app, it's slower to motorboat and reasonably laggy portion browsing the web and juggling tabs. Microsoft Edge, connected the different hand, is snappier each astir due to the fact that it's a autochthonal ARM app.

I typically tally aggregate browsers astatine once, since it's the easiest mode to abstracted enactment and idiosyncratic accounts. I can't conscionable determination to Edge afloat time. So if I wanted to enactment the mode I'm utilized to connected the Surface Pro 9 with 5G, I'd conscionable person to unrecorded with an acquisition that's worse than a three-year-old Surface Laptop. Does that dependable similar advancement to you? While it performed mostly good with autochthonal apps similar Spotify and Evernote, multitasking betwixt them and emulated apps inactive felt noticeably sluggish. In galore ways, it felt similar a measurement down from the Surface Pro 6 I reviewed 4 years ago, prevention for the silkier 120Hz refresh complaint connected the Pro 9's larger screen.

All of the benchmarks I ran connected the Surface Pro 9 besides amusement that it's slower than immoderate premium laptop we've reviewed implicit the past fewer years. Sure, Geekbench 5 was moving arsenic a slower emulated app, but its people is besides indicative of however different emulated programs volition run. Even the anemic Surface Go 2, with its low-power 11th-gen Intel chip, managed to outperform the Pro 9 5G successful single-core performance. (At slightest the SQ3 faired amended with multi-core speeds.) 3DMark's Wildlife Extreme test, which is 1 of the champion ways to comparison cross-platform gaming, besides returned a debased score, arsenic I expected. (The bigger surprise? It was connected par with the ASUS ZenBook Fold 17, a foldable machine held backmost by a low-wattage Intel chip.)

While I don't deliberation galore radical would beryllium buying the 5G Surface Pro 9 for its show alone, it's inactive worthy reiterating that it'll beryllium a acold slower machine than its Intel counterpart. I didn't person that different Pro 9 exemplary to test, but we did reappraisal the ASUS ZenBook Fold 17, which uses a akin Intel Core i7-1250U CPU. That's a low-power spot but different comparable to the i7-1255U connected the Surface Pro 9. Compared to the SQ3 Pro 9, the ZenBook blew it distant successful Geekbench 5's CPU test, arsenic good arsenic Cinebench R23.

Surprisingly, some the ZenBook Fold 17 and 5G Pro 9 scored likewise successful the Wildlife Extreme benchmark, but the Intel spot has the vantage of being capable to tally games natively. The Pro 9 5G couldn't adjacent successfully emulate older titles similar Quake connected Steam. (For the genuinely desperate, you tin ever watercourse Xbox Game Pass titles implicit the cloud, and a fistful of low-power autochthonal games similar Minecraft tally fine.)

Devindra Hardawar/Engadget

What bully is built-in cellular?

The Surface Pro 9's built-in 5G connectivity gives it 1 large limb up implicit the Intel model, but I didn't find it precise compelling during my testing. During cellular setup, Windows directed maine to Ubigi and Gigsky arsenic 2 imaginable providers that would link to the Surface's eSIM. I went with Ubigi, and aft 20 minutes of relationship setup, I was capable to hop onto their LTE network. Unfortunately, I didn't spot immoderate 5G speeds successful my Atlanta suburb, but the web inactive delivered a respectable 33.6 Mbps down and (far little impressive) 2 Mbps up implicit LTE.

If you already person a moving SIM card, you tin unfastened up the Pro 9's enlargement country nether the kickstand and descent it successful there. My Verizon SIM was recognized successful 30 seconds, and it delivered 50 Mbps down and 4 Mbps up implicit LTE. You tin besides easy swap retired the notebook's SSD successful that enlargement country too, thing we could ne'er bash before. In exchange, though, Microsoft removed the SD paper slot. I wouldn't see that a dealbreaker — being capable to upgrade to a larger SSD down the enactment is incredibly utile — but it's thing to support successful caput if you trust connected SD cards to store your euphony oregon photos.

Having the quality to hop connected cellular everywhere, particularly for planetary providers similar Ubigi, is surely impressive. Personally, though, I'd commercialized that successful for the accrued velocity and app compatibility from the Intel Surface Pro 9. Is it truly that pugnacious to tether your phone? And existent roadworthy warriors are apt amended disconnected with a mobile hotspot, which tin link to aggregate devices easily.

Devindra Hardawar/Engadget

Same Surface issues, 10 years later

Perhaps I'm conscionable grumpy from the full forced ARM transition, but I besides couldn't assistance but beryllium frustrated by the different annoyances from the Surface Pro 9. Microsoft has been pumping these things retired for a decennary now, and they're inactive annoying to usage connected your lap. Unlike a accepted laptop, which has a level basal connected to a screen, you person to juggle the Surface's keyboard screen and kickstand connected your limb to support it propped up. It's functional capable — I was capable to benignant this full reappraisal with the Surface connected my thigh — but not precisely comfortable.

I've been capable to carnivore it for years, but by this point, it'd beryllium bully to spot Microsoft effort something to amended the experience. Maybe adhd a secondary hinge to stabilize things, oregon connection a lawsuit that tin wholly unify the keyboard and tablet (like HP's leather-clad Spectre Folio). With ultraportables similar the MacBook Air and Dell XPS 13 getting lighter and thinner each year, Microsoft can't conscionable presume consumers volition unrecorded with subpar ergonomics. Perhaps the tradeoff would beryllium worthy it if the Surface was usable arsenic a tablet connected its own, but I inactive find it excessively ample and unwieldy compared to the iPad Pro. (And it’s not similar Windows is immoderate amended connected tablets, either.)

There are inactive immoderate bully plan ideas astir the Surface — I emotion the mode the Slim Pen 2 hides distant successful the $180 Signature Pro keyboard, and it remains 1 of the champion stylii connected the marketplace erstwhile it comes to drafting and jotting down notes. Still, it feels similar the Surface is turning into a machine that's much performative than it is functional. Look astatine its kickstand! Don't interest astir however impractical it is. It's got 5G! But disregard the information that it has a dilatory mobile processor. Even its 2 USB-C ports are compromised; they're constricted to USB 3.2, whereas the Intel model's ports each enactment the faster Thunderbolt 4 standard.

AI-assisted video chats

Oddly enough, there's 1 happening the 5G Surface Pro 9 excels at: video calls. It sports a crisp 1080p front-facing camera, but crucially, it's assisted by the SQ3's Neural Processing Unit. That powers features similar automatic framing, inheritance blurring and sustained oculus interaction during video calls. And successful my experience, it's astir magical. The representation blurring effects are adjacent to what I'd expect from a larger DSLR camera, and the automatic framing was silky smooth. Those features besides enactment crossed immoderate video chat app, truthful you don't person to interest astir looking antithetic crossed Zoom oregon Teams.

The 1 downside of the Intel-powered Surface Pro 9 is that it can't instrumentality vantage of immoderate of those features. While Intel's 12th-gen CPUs are plentifulness powerful, they don't person an NPU built-in. Microsoft reps accidental immoderate aboriginal chips that adhd AI processing volition beryllium capable to usage these features, but that doesn't assistance radical buying Intel Pro 9 models this year. At the precise least, they'll person a bully front-facing camera (as good arsenic a precise susceptible 10-megapixel rear camera).

Devindra Hardawar/Engadget

Wrap-up

If you're inactive funny successful the 5G Surface Pro 9, having work my complaints and frustrations, beryllium prepared to wage dearly. It starts astatine $1,300 with a comparatively humble 8GB of RAM and a 128GB SSD, portion the Intel exemplary goes for $1,000 with those aforesaid specs. And if you privation a keyboard, adhd different $120 for the Pro Type Cover (though we’d urge the $140 Pro Keyboard instead). Jumping up to 16GB of RAM with the 5G Pro 9 (like our reappraisal unit) volition outgo you $1,600 with 256GB of storage. As you spell up the terms range, the Intel and SQ3 models extremity up costing the aforesaid — but who wants to wage astir $2,000 for an ARM-based Windows PC?

Perhaps 1 day, Microsoft's imagination of an ultra-thin, ARM-powered Surface volition travel true. But the institution has failed astatine each effort to marque that hap (my condolences to anyone who bought the Surface RT). The 5G Pro 9 is an improvement, but its quality belies its galore applicable issues. If you're astatine each funny successful a caller Surface, bargain the Intel exemplary and get a hotspot connected the side. You'll beryllium acold happier.