The Deep Voice, the Black Turtleneck & the $1 Billion Lie: Why Elizabeth Holmes Is Endlessly Fascinating

2 years ago 37

Emmys 2022: Why We're Excited for TV's Biggest Night

Anyone other consciousness similar their full societal media provender has been obsessed with Elizabeth Holmes for years?

If that sanction sounds acquainted to you, it's not due to the fact that she's that miss from your hometown who conscionable got engaged. And no, she's not 1 of the students who got caught successful in the assemblage admissions scandal. She's the inventor of Theranos, the reputedly $10 cardinal dollar institution that was astir to revolutionize the wellness attraction system...except it ne'er did due to the fact that it was each based connected mendacious promises, raising astir $1 cardinal dollars by lying to investors.

The epic emergence and autumn of Theranos and Holmes, 38, has each the makings of a classic Hollywood tale: secret bureau romances, fake voices, tons of lies, tons of wealth and, of course, a compelling anti-hero astatine the halfway of it all.

And Hollywood has decidedly taken notice, with the Theranos ungraded receiving the popular civilization mentation of an EGOT: It inspired a best-selling publication (Bad Blood), the HBO documentary The Inventor: Out for Blood successful Silicon Valley, a deed podcast called The Dropout, and, of course, Hulu's constricted bid based connected said podcast.

The amusement is in contention for six awards astatine the 2022 Emmys, including Outstanding Limited oregon Anthology series, and prima Amanda Seyfried was nominated for her portrayal of the arguable figure, proving not adjacent Emmy voters tin get capable of the Theranos story. 

Oh, and determination is inactive adjacent much Holmes-related contented to travel as Jennifer Lawrence will portrayal Holmes in Adam McKay's upcoming movie, which has yet to commencement filming oregon denote a merchandise date. 

So wherefore are we each truthful fascinated by Holmes, who was just 19 years aged erstwhile she dropped retired of Stanford to commencement her bio-tech institution that had galore radical successful Silicon Valley naming her the adjacent Steve Jobs (except successful the end, you know, his tech really worked)? 

To rapidly springiness you an thought of however crazy-successful Holmes had made Theranos, conscionable look astatine the caliber of radical Holmes was capable to person backing oregon enactment from implicit the years earlier the Wall Street Journal archetypal reported the company's then-alleged fraud successful 2015: A erstwhile president, Bill Clinton, 2 erstwhile Secretary of States, Henry Kissinger and George Shultz, 2 senators, Trump medication Secretary of Education Betsy DeVos, a partridge and a pear tree. 

David Orrell/CNBC/NBCU Photo Bank via Getty Images

How Holmes, who with conscionable 1 afloat twelvemonth astatine Stanford nether her belt, was capable to unafraid $10 cardinal successful backing and a spot on TIME 100's database of the world's astir influential radical successful 2014, was capable to propulsion it each disconnected is 1 of the astir intriguing and mystifying aspects to her story. 

And similar with immoderate bully story, person to spell backmost to the beginning, arsenic her ambition to alteration the satellite started astatine a young age. 

The girl of a Congressional committee staffer and an Enron employee, Holmes ever had large plans for her future, drafting a sketch of a clip instrumentality erstwhile she was conscionable 7, and telling her begetter astatine the property of 9, according to a New Yorker profile, "What I truly privation retired of beingness is to observe thing new, thing that mankind didn't cognize was imaginable to do." 

There is nary imagination you can’t achieve. Don’t fto anyone archer you otherwise. #ILookLikeAnEngineer pic.twitter.com/RxiAhXdP89

— Elizabeth Holmes (@eholmes2003) August 20, 2015

According to a household person quoted successful John Carreyrou's 2018 best-seller Bad Blood: Secrets and Lies successful a Silicon Valley Startup, Holmes would often reply the question of what she wanted to beryllium erstwhile she grew up with: "a billionaire." When the follow-up question was, "Don't you privation to beryllium the president?" she responded, "No, the president volition privation to wed maine due to the fact that I'll person truthful overmuch money."

By 31, she was touted arsenic the youngest self-made pistillate billionaire successful the U.S. by Forbes (Kylie Jenner secured that rubric successful 2019).

But successful an interrogation connected CBS This Morning, Holmes said it wasn't each astir the Benjamins for her anymore.

Beth Dubber/Hulu

"You know, it's not what matters," Holmes said. "What matters is however good we bash successful trying to marque people's lives better. That's wherefore I'm doing this. That's wherefore I enactment the mode that I work. And that's wherefore I emotion what I'm doing truthful much."

Holmes' thought for Theranos (therapy and diagnosis combined to signifier 1 word, by the way) was calved retired of her fearfulness of needles ("I detest [them] deeply," she erstwhile told Glamour) and the nonaccomplishment of her uncle to cancer, an anecdote she often repeated successful interviews and speeches. "I retrieve however overmuch I loved him," she would say. "He didn't unrecorded to spot his lad turn up and I ne'er got to accidental goodbye." 

According to Holmes, Theranos' tech, a bio-chip, would beryllium capable to trial for hundreds of aesculapian conditions with a azygous driblet of blood. 

"Making it imaginable to bash tests connected tiny samples; immoderate crab patient, immoderate child, immoderate aged idiosyncratic whose veins illness volition archer you not having to person their humor drawn that mode is simply a large deal," Holmes explained to CBS This Morning.

In a word, it was revolutionary. The lone occupation was it was impossible, which a Stanford prof told Holmes earlier she dropped out. 

 Dr. Phyllis Gardner, a prof of medicine astatine Stanford, told The Dropout podcast, "One time she came to maine and she described her idea...you can't bash that, it's impossible, physically. I said, 'Elizabeth...I don't deliberation that's going to work.'" 

Still, she persisted. "She ne'er thought she had immoderate limits."

Courtesy of HBO, Beth Dubber/Hulu

But Channing Robertson, the well-respected caput of the Stanford subject department, afloat believed successful Holmes and her vision, yet leaving his presumption astatine the assemblage to enactment for her. 

"When I yet connected with what Elizabeth fundamentally is, I realized that I could person conscionable arsenic good been looking into the eyes of a Steve Jobs or a Bill Gates," Robertson told Fortune in 2014.

Carreyrou, who wrote the Wall Street Journal nonfiction that sparked Theranos' downfall earlier penning Bad Blood, spoke astir Holmes' powers of persuasion connected a Vanity Fair podcast.

"This is benignant of a arguable taxable present amid the MeToo question but it's undeniable that her marks, again and again, were older men," helium said. "She wowed them. I don't needfully deliberation that it was a intersexual happening by immoderate means...I deliberation it was a operation of her intelligence, a operation of her charisma, her bold vision, her energy, each of that successful 1 package."

During the TCA sheet for The Inventor successful February, erstwhile worker and whistleblower Tyler Shultz (grandson of 1 of Holmes' biggest supporters and Theranos committee subordinate Howard Shultz), spoke to Holmes' charisma, saying she "made you consciousness similar you were the astir important idiosyncratic to her and you were captious to achieving the imaginativeness she had sold you on." He described her arsenic having a "reality distortion tract she walked astir with."

And successful an interrogation with the LA Times, Shultz said it's casual to look backmost present and spot the informing signs, but hindsight is, arsenic it ever successful in these benignant of situations, 20/20. "Once you cognize the truth, it's truly casual to spot it," helium said, "but erstwhile you don't—Elizabeth had this mode of locking you in." 

Getty Images

She looked the part. She sounded the part. She acted the part. Everyone wanted to judge it was the existent deal. 

"She whitethorn beryllium the pistillate Mark Zuckerberg that Silicon Valley has been waiting for," Vivek Wadhwa, a prof and researcher astatine Stanford and Duke, said successful 2014. "She started erstwhile she was young, defied the likelihood and built a large technology, and is doing bully for the world."

In a 2014 New Yorker profile, Theranos committee subordinate and erstwhile U.S. Defense Secretary William J. Perry gushed, "She has sometimes been called different Steve Jobs, but I deliberation that's an inadequate comparison. She has a societal consciousness that Steve ne'er had. He was a genius; she's 1 with a large heart."

Also, she was conscionable a precise absorbing person. Just look astatine this paragraph describing her idiosyncratic beingness (or deficiency thereof) successful that aforesaid New Yorker piece:

Her location is simply a two-bedroom condo successful Palo Alto, and she lives an austere life. Although she tin punctuation Jane Austen by heart, she nary longer devotes clip to novels oregon friends, doesn't date, doesn't ain a television, and hasn't taken a abrogation successful 10 years. Her refrigerator is each but empty, arsenic she eats astir of her meals astatine the office. She is simply a vegan, and respective times a time she drinks a pulverized concoction of cucumber, parsley, kale, spinach, romaine lettuce, and celery.

But the item attracting the astir attraction from radical (pre and post-downfall) was Holmes' voice. It was shockingly debased and deep, an awesome baritone that instantly made you lean successful conscionable a small spot person erstwhile she was speaking. 

But many, including her erstwhile Stanford professor, said it wasn't however she really sounded, with Gardner saying, "When she came to maine she didn't person a debased voice."

"I deliberation it was astatine 1 of the institution parties, and possibly she had excessively overmuch to portion oregon what not, but she fell retired of quality and she exposed that that was not needfully her existent voice," erstwhile Theranos worker Ana Arriola said successful an occurrence of The Dropout. "Maybe she needed to beryllium much convincing to task a persona wrong a country amongst antheral VC?  I'm not truly rather sure."

Justin Sullivan/Getty Images

Along with Jobs' right-hand antheral Avie Tevanian, Arriola was 1 of Holmes' galore recruits from Apple, which played into her obsession with its precocious founder. In fact, Arriola, who helped travel up with the plan of the iPhone, gave up 15,000 shares successful Apple banal to articulation Theranos aft a gathering with Holmes. 

"It sounded similar an incredibly compelling mission, that was fundamentally truly reasoning astir the betterment of humanity," Arriola explained. "She's incredibly passionate, she's precise energetic, precise expressive with her hands and has a precise unique, distinctive dependable that you benignant of get drawn into what it is she's conveying." 

Aside from allegedly changing her voice, determination was besides a displacement successful however she dressed.

When Arriola archetypal joined the start-up, Holmes would deterioration these "frumpy Christmas sweaters" earlier yet asking the ex-Apple employees astir Jobs' infamous attire. 

When she learned Jobs exclusively wore achromatic Issey Miyake turtlenecks, Arriola said, "I deliberation she went disconnected and tracked down who Issey Miyake was and the remainder is couture history...she did alteration her aesthetic." 

But Holmes told Glamour in 2015 that she had ever been wearing achromatic turtlenecks and they were simply a signifier successful practicality. 

"My ma had maine successful achromatic turtlenecks erstwhile I was, like, eight," she said. "I astir apt person 150 of these. [It's] my uniform. It makes it easy, due to the fact that each time you enactment connected the aforesaid happening and don't person to deliberation astir it—one little happening successful your life. All my absorption is connected the work. I instrumentality it truthful seriously; I'm definite that translates into however I dress."

Then there's besides her dog, Balto, Siberian husky she flew archetypal people crossed the state to prime up from a canine breeder erstwhile helium was 9 weeks old, according to Vanity Fair. (This was successful September 2017, truthful good aft Theranos' troubles had started.)

Though Balto wasn't potty-trained, Holmes inactive brought him into the Theranos labs each day, with the mag reporting, "While Holmes held committee meetings, Balto could beryllium recovered successful the country of the country relieving himself portion a frenzied adjunct was near to cleanable up the mess." 

It gets weirder: When Holmes discovered Balto had a tiny hint of wolf origin, which galore huskies do, she began answering, "He's a wolf," erstwhile asked by radical what his breed was. 

There were different weird quirks employees picked up on, per Vanity Fair—she had bodyguards who referred to her arsenic "Eagle One," she didn't blink, she could beryllium spotted "rocking and slamming her caput to hip-hop music" unsocial successful her car successful the parking batch and would archer lies, similar saying she was at location erstwhile she was successful an bureau down the hallway from the worker she was e-mailing—and yet, galore of her recruits "idolized" her, with Holmes hiring immoderate of the apical endowment successful Silicon Valley to enactment astatine Theranos.

"For being a pistillate successful the sciences, being a pistillate successful tech," erstwhile laboratory tech Erika Cheung, different whistleblower, said successful The Inventor. "The information that she started her ain company, that got maine truly excited. She was a truly bully idol to have."

Justin Maxwell, 1 of the many who made the determination implicit from Apple, said "Elizabeth did bash a large occupation of recruiting astonishing people."

But the turnover complaint astatine Theranos was precocious and he'd ticker arsenic radical helium truly respected "just disappeared." He explained that disagreeing oregon questioning thing Holmes said was risky and could often effect successful losing your job.  

Justin Sullivan/Getty Images

"Anyone who told Elizabeth 'no'…you were instantly terminated," helium said. "It was a precise antithetic environment."

Adding to the antithetic situation was the beingness of Sunny Balwani, the company's president and Chief Operating Officer, who was besides Holmes' boyfriend, though they ne'er disclosed their narration to investors. Their erstwhile narration presumption remained unconfirmed until deposition tapes pertaining to the transgression lawsuit against them were released successful January 2019.

Some of her committee members adjacent tried to acceptable her up connected dates implicit the years, with Holmes ever declining.  "My woman and I consciousness that 1 of our jobs is to bring her out," George Shultz told the New Yorker.

Holmes archetypal met Balwani, who was astir 20 years her senior, during a trip to Beijing with Stanford aft she had graduated precocious school, though they didn't participate a romanticist narration until aft she dropped retired college, with Carreyrou penning successful Bad Blood that the mates were surviving unneurotic by 2005. 

Though he didn't person acquisition successful biomedical engineering, Balwani joined Theranos successful 2009, rapidly becoming the company's COO. 

In an interrogation with Business Insider, Carreyrou recounted what a root had told him astir the concealed couple's dynamic, though astir employees had nary thought they were dating. 

"[My source] made precise wide to maine that they were moving this happening arsenic a partnership, and that Sunny was benignant of the enforcer and Holmes' older boyfriend," the writer explained. "He painted the representation of this fraud being tally by a couple."

Justin Sullivan/Getty Images

At Theranos, Balwani was a "menacing" figure; he'd often way erstwhile employees arrived and left, springiness institution speeches that often-included chanting "f--k you!" erstwhile talking astir the company's competitors oregon detractors, and "would conscionable get truthful aggravated oregon upset and was not well-versed successful the sciences...and would often accidental things that were frankly inappropriate," according to Cheung connected The Dropout

"He was terse and helium was a spot of a hothead," Michael Craig, a erstwhile worker said connected the podcast. "There was 1 level, this request to asseverate dominance, and different level, I don't deliberation helium ran unspeakable deep...he has that request to beryllium himself and besides pretending similar he's supra everything."

His nickname successful the office? "The Enforcer," according to Tyler Shultz, employing "intimidation tactics." 

And similar his girlfriend, employees besides noted immoderate unusual things: He kept samurai swords successful his bureau and drove a achromatic Lamborghini with a licence sheet that work "VDIVICI" successful homage to Julius Caesar's' famous operation that translates to "I came, I saw, I conquered."

While she was secretly dating the president of her institution (who had invested $13 cardinal of his ain wealth with nary interest), Holmes, the sole pistillate subordinate of Theranos' 12-person board, often often spoke astir shattering the solid ceiling and inspiring different women.

"If I tin amusement that successful this country, a 19-year-old miss tin driblet retired of schoolhouse and physique thing similar this," she said successful an interrogation with The Mercury News in 2014, "then different women should beryllium doing it."

But past it each came crashing down successful 2015.

After the Wall Street Journal nonfiction came out, Holmes defended Theranos' credibility and vision.

"This is what happens erstwhile you enactment to alteration things," she said during an quality connected CNBC's Mad Money. "First they deliberation you're crazy, past they combat you, and then, each of a sudden, you alteration the world."

By 2018 though, Theranos officially unopen down, with Balwani having near the institution successful 2016 aft helium and Holmes broke up. 

"Once we started moving unneurotic it was a precise aggravated narration and that romanticist portion that was determination astatine the precise opening died," Holmes testified successful her deposition, according to audio in The Dropout. "I don't deliberation it happened successful 1 moment, but it was precise wide we were colleagues."

While she didn't admit to immoderate wrongdoing, Holmes paid a $500,000 good and was barred from being an serviceman oregon manager of a nationalist institution for 10 years successful the SEC case, which charged the laminitis and Balwani with "massive fraud" for falsifying oregon exaggerating claims astir the accuracy of the tech.

And successful January 2022, Holmes was acquitted connected charges of defrauding patients but was recovered guilty of conspiracy to perpetrate ligament fraud and 3 counts of ligament fraud for lying to her investors. Each count of fraud includes a maximum situation condemnation of 20 years, according to The New York Times, which notes the sentences are "likely to beryllium served concurrently."

However, the assemblage decided she was not blameworthy of a 2nd number of conspiracy to perpetrate ligament fraud, and they reached nary verdict connected 3 much counts of ligament fraud. 

Balwani, meanwhile, was convicted connected each 12 counts of ligament fraud and conspiracy to perpetrate ligament fraud successful July.

While Holmes awaits her last sentencing connected Oct. 17, she is presently spending clip with her partner, edifice heir Billy Evans, and their son, William Holmes Evans, was born July 2021. 

"For the ending, we initially had envisioned it astatine Burning Man," The Dropout showrunner Elizabeth Meriweather revealed to The Hollywood Reporter, "because she made this travel to Burning Man with her caller fiancé, Billy, and they had posted each implicit Instagram astir it, and it conscionable felt similar a truly absorbing spot for a quote-unquote rebirth."

Instead, the Hulu amusement ended with Holmes seeking refuge from a pissed disconnected worker by calling an Uber.

But Holmes' quality to disconnect from Theranos' downfall and enactment successful the desert was conscionable different portion successful the puzzle of wherefore radical can't get capable of her story.

Justin Sullivan/Getty Images

"It's mind-blowing successful galore ways and says a batch astir ambition and drive," Elizabeth Jarvis, the big of The Dropout podcast, told the LA Times. "In bid to person an Elizabeth Holmes, you besides person to person galore different radical and institutions fail. It raises questions astir Silicon Valley, astir the media and astir our willingness to bargain a well-crafted communicative without a batch of substance. Elizabeth convinced truthful galore supposedly astute radical to bargain into her communicative and enactment their reputations connected that enactment for her, which makes the assemblage inquire questions astir themselves. I deliberation that is wherefore radical support coming backmost to it."

Even backmost successful 2019, Holmes was acceptable for redemption.

"Elizabeth sees herself arsenic the victim," a root adjacent to Holmes told Vanity Fair, which besides reported astatine the clip that she was looking into partnering with a filmmaker to archer her broadside of the story, arsenic good as planning to constitute a book. 

According to a source: "One of Elizabeth's superpowers is she ne'er looks back."

(Originally published Tuesday, March 19, 2019 astatine 2:45 p.m. PT)

Don't miss E!'s unrecorded 2022 Emmys reddish carpet sum Monday, Sept. 12, starting astatine 5 p.m. ET/2 p.m. PT followed by the Emmy Awards ceremonial astatine 8 p.m. ET/5 p.m. PT connected NBC and Peacock.

Read Entire Article