Five years ago, it seemed similar travel orchestration exertion was having a moment. 

Since then, the marketplace for standalone travel orchestration motor (JOE) platforms has receded. A plateau successful income and galore vendor acquisitions absorbed astir each the autarkic JOE vendors. 

What happened, and what does it mean for you, the martech leader?

First, a spot of history

JOE exertion has roots successful the pre-digital era, wherever galore “decisioning” platforms helped pass nonstop message and telephony-based lawsuit engagement.

Vendors similar Infor, SAS, and Pega acquired and merged overmuch of this tech into larger suites and dilatory adapted them to the integer age.

Then the 2010s saw galore enterprises undertake “customer travel mapping” projects, often led by outer agencies conducting specialized workshops to uncover “as-is” and “to-be” lawsuit journeys. 

The diverseness of approaches to visualization, terminology, and adjacent the explanation of a “journey” should person been a informing that full-cycle orchestration would beryllium difficult. 

Not surprisingly, astir of these projects led to much tactical, test-and-optimize projects astatine discrete touchpoints alternatively than systemic omnichannel overhauls.

Read next: What is lawsuit travel orchestration and however does it work?

Promise and pitfalls

At the aforesaid time, a fistful of independent, born-digital JOE vendors emerged. They served forward-looking enterprises seeking to supply a much coherent, omnichannel acquisition for customers. 

Interestingly, the lawsuit information level (CDP) marketplace — which emerged simultaneously — grew to go a multi-billion dollar arena with dozens of plausible alternatives.

Yet, the JOE marketplace ne'er truly took off. Why not?

First of all, omnichannel travel orchestration is much analyzable than it looks. An endeavor specializer mightiness ideate themself sitting astatine a analyzable power panel, adjusting dials and knobs to optimize outcomes.

But it turns retired that modern lawsuit engagement tin beryllium arsenic analyzable arsenic atomic controls, and necessitate comparable levels of education, grooming and hazard reduction. 

For JOE exertion to work, you request to person astatine slightest 3 things successful place, and nary of them are easy:

• Comprehensive, unified and accessible lawsuit data. Almost nary steadfast has this, though everyone is moving connected it. Sometimes JOE vendors would physique successful mini-CDPs conscionable to accelerate this process, with predictably mediocre results.
• Performant, reliable, customizable, bi-directional connectors to your astir important lawsuit engagement touchpoints truthful you tin adequately perceive and respond. The word “reliable connector” should springiness you pause.
• Interdepartmental strategy and governance to fig retired and past execute your tactics crossed galore channels: media buys, web, apps, messaging-oriented campaigns, e-commerce, and lawsuit service. Often, we spot selling instrumentality the pb here, but this is an enterprise-wide endeavor, and those are hard.

---

---

A changing market

After archetypal excitement, the JOE marketplace plateaued.

Salesforce dropped its reseller statement with the largest indie JOE vendor, Thunderhead. Acquia softly dismissed its JOE partner, Kitewheel. 

Other suite vendors similar Adobe and Acoustic lone person constricted investments successful omnichannel orchestration arsenic they absorption much connected outbound messaging platforms.

Most pointedly, each the large JOE independents person gotten sold off, chiefly to “CX” (read: lawsuit listening/service) vendors similar Medallia and Qualtrics. 

Here again, the opposition with CDPs feels apt. CDPs person go astir a “cost of doing business.” In astir cases, the ample endeavor needs to deploy one. 

Yet JOE exertion has remained much aspirational, requiring a tougher instrumentality connected concern justification. Recent M&A enactment seems to bespeak the astir profitable happening JOE exertion does circa 2022 is to trim some lawsuit churn and costly telephone halfway volumes. 

The aboriginal of travel orchestration technology

This communicative doesn’t person a bittersweet ending. The request for travel orchestration is not going away. 

While marketers whitethorn stay enamored with outbound, message-oriented campaigns, consumers are little optimistic astir the resulting deluge of emails, texts, and in-app messages. 

The listen-and-respond motif of travel orchestration platforms volition go adjacent much captious arsenic firms modulation to subscription-like models that stress maximizing beingness lawsuit value.

Meanwhile, a increasing acceptable of CDP vendors is adding lightweight orchestration services to their platforms.

At first, we astatine Real Story Group were skeptical astatine this CDP+journey coupling — due separation of concerns and each that. Yet, we’ve learned that decisioning seems to privation to reside adjacent to data. 

Some of our clients find this bundled attack a utile instauration to a analyzable opportunity.

They are already moving much heavy-duty artificial quality and instrumentality learning operations little successful their information stack (where they tin beryllium much intimately governed). Putting a light, data-centric orchestration furniture connected apical could contiguous a elemental mode to leverage immoderate of those models.

In immoderate case, decisioning and travel orchestration are not going away. Instead, they’ll instrumentality much clip to mature connected some the vendor and endeavor sides.

Larger questions revolve astir wherever these services volition reside successful your aboriginal stack. And for that, you person galore choices.

---

Opinions expressed successful this nonfiction are those of the impermanent writer and not needfully MarTech. Staff authors are listed here.

---